Skip to content
Peep & Pen

Stage 0 — deciding and planning

The mistakes that cost you money, and the two that cost you birds

Most first-year errors are cheap and funny. Two are neither, and both are decisions made at a hardware store or a farm store before the birds ever arrive.

By Scooter M.·Published September 1, 2026

A person holding a hen in both hands

The short answer

Two first-year mistakes actually cost birds: using chicken wire instead of half-inch hardware cloth, and sealing the coop up for winter instead of ventilating it. The rest — buying the coop first, overstocking on a capacity claim, feeding layer pellets to pullets — cost money and are easy to reverse.

The two that cost birds

Chicken wire is not predator-proofing. This is the single most consequential mistake in backyard chicken keeping and it is entirely a purchasing decision. Chicken wire is a light twisted hexagonal mesh designed to keep chickens contained. A raccoon reaches through it. A weasel passes through it. A determined dog goes through it. The material that excludes those animals is welded hardware cloth in half-inch mesh, 19 gauge, and the price difference is the reason people get this wrong. Predator-proofing covers the mesh, the apron and the hardware.

Sealing the coop for winter causes the frostbite it was meant to prevent. The reasoning feels sound — it is cold, so close the gaps — and it is exactly backwards. A closed coop full of birds becomes humid overnight from respiration and droppings, that moisture condenses on combs and wattles, and that is what freezes. Chickens tolerate dry cold remarkably well. What they cannot tolerate is damp. Ventilation versus draft is the distinction, and it is the most useful thing a first-time keeper can learn about winter.

The ones that just cost money

  • Buying the coop first. It is the fun purchase and the one you have the most time for. Chicks do not go outside for five or six weeks. Order the coop in week three, when you know how many birds you actually have.
  • Trusting the number on the coop box. Do the division. Interior floor area divided by stated bird count, compared against the 3 to 4 square feet per hen that poultry.extension.org publishes. Coops that state six birds routinely work out to 1.3 square feet each.
  • A heat lamp in the brooder. Twenty times the running cost of a plate and the leading cause of brooder fires.
  • Feeding layer feed to pullets. Layer feed is high in calcium for shell formation. Growing birds that are not laying cannot use it and their kidneys pay for the excess. Purina’s own direction is to feed starter until the onset of egg production and then switch.
  • Leaving feed out overnight. This is the decision that determines whether you get rats. Not the presence of chickens — the presence of free food after dark.
  • Buying a small feeder and a small waterer. You will replace both within a season. Published birds-per-nipple and days-of-feed ratings let you buy once.

The ones about the birds rather than the gear

  • Adding new birds straight into the flock. Chickens have a real hierarchy and a new bird dropped into an established one gets attacked. New birds are introduced through a barrier over a week or more, not tipped in.
  • Not having nest boxes ready before week sixteen. Wherever a pullet lays for her first fortnight is where she will keep laying. Boxes go in before the first egg, not after you find one behind the compost.
  • Naming the meat birds. Nothing to add here except that everybody is told this and nobody listens.
  • Assuming a broody hen is ill. A hen sitting flat in a nest box, fluffed up and growling at you, is broody, not sick. It is a hormonal state and it passes.
FAQ

Questions people actually ask

What is the most common mistake new chicken owners make?

Using chicken wire instead of half-inch hardware cloth. Chicken wire is designed to contain chickens, not exclude predators: a raccoon can reach through it and a weasel can pass through it entirely. It is a purchasing decision made before the birds arrive, and it is the mistake most likely to lose a whole flock in one night.

Should I insulate or seal my chicken coop for winter?

No. Sealing a coop traps the moisture the birds produce through respiration and droppings, and that moisture condenses on combs and wattles and causes frostbite. Chickens handle dry cold well. Ventilate high, above roosting height, so damp air escapes without blowing directly on the birds.

Can I feed layer feed to young chickens?

No. Layer feed carries the calcium a laying hen needs to form shells, and a growing bird that is not laying cannot use it. Purina's own feeding direction is to feed chick starter continuously from day one until the onset of egg production and then switch to a layer feed.

How do I introduce new chickens to an existing flock?

Gradually and through a barrier. Chickens have a real social hierarchy and a bird added directly to an established flock will be attacked. House the new birds where the flock can see but not reach them for a week or more, then allow supervised contact, ideally with space and multiple feeders so nobody can be cornered.

Where the numbers came from

Sources

Every figure cited on this page came from one of these documents. If one of them has changed since we read it, the number here is out of date and we would like to know.

Keep reading